Saturday, 8 November 2014

The China Live Animal Exports Debate

I find the current debate about live cattle export to China fascinating.  And I will declare I am not a supporter of live animal transport be it cattle, pigs or sheep. 

No one with any heart can view images of cattle; sheep or pigs stuck in the bowels of transport ships for weeks and not be moved to tears. Or watch some of the practices in slaughterhouses overseas and not feel revolted.  I feel exactly the same about animals stuck in feed lots on our shores. Pigs confined to pig stalls where they can’t move and most can barely stand-up. They never see the sun on their faces and they live a life of misery until they are transported to slaughterhouses to face even more terror.  Let’s not forget about chickens and battery farms. Once again, live creatures subjected to misery cramped together in the most awful environments and then rammed into cages and off to be killed.   
People tend to focus on slaughtering and forget about what comes before. They hide behind the ‘cry’ that we kill humanely. I personally fail to see how being stunned before having your throat cut is humane. It’s less barbaric arguably but it’s not and never was humane. Perhaps it’s just a little less stressful and a slightly ‘easier’ death than some other practices we read about.  For what it is worth it’s even worse for chickens. Whilst I’m on this topic being corralled in a pen waiting for their turn to be murdered isn’t pleasant for any animal. They smell death and they suffer extreme anxiety. Before anyone jumps to the conclusion that I’m an inner city greenie, I will point out I was born and raised in the country. My father was a farmer so I have witnessed practices first hand.

By all means we should speak up about cruel practices but in all conscious we can’t condemn others and then conveniently turn a blind-eye to what happens on our own doorsteps. Some of the most vocal never ever utter a word about pig pens, feed lots or battery farms. I would be on a safe bet in saying that many of those ‘shouting their mouths off’ about the deal with China have tucked into their bacon and eggs this morning with nary a thought for what happened before their food hit their plates. 
As with so many things in life money will continue to drive our live export industry. It’s big business. We can only hope to minimise the impact on animals.  It’s the same for the less than desirable practices on our own shores (depending on your view of course). But please let’s cease the hypocrisy of the faux outrage over live exports and continue to ignore what happens here. The argument about its less cruel doesn’t overcome the fact that raising animals for human consumption involves a level of cruelty. Some people can accept that which is their right of course. But if you do have an issue with it, do what I did and become a vegetarian.